Forschungsergebnisse

19.07.2004

Quelle:

Autor

Verfasser

Aires Gameiro, Director, São João de Deus Mental Health Center, Funchal, Madeira /
Past-Director, Mental Health Center of São Miguel, Azores

Thema:

Identity Formation and Risk Factors for Azorean Women’s Health

This paper, presented at the Conference Women in the Azores and the Immigrant Communities held in July of 2001, analyzes some current problems related to the personal identity formation and social integration of Azorean women in relation to stress and substance abuse. It deals with psychosocial and cultural factors, specially those that are more significant to the development of personal identity. The cultural and conflictual fragmentation so characteristic of this Post-modern period generates not only freedom to make choices, but also the tendency toward stress and dependencies. The current situation of women is analyzed in relation to these two tendencies. Also highlighted are the added difficulties of about 5% of the population affected by genetic and environmental factors. Current cultural trends are considered as a source of opportunities and risks for women, since they can enrich the process of personal and social identity formation or promote risky consumption and jeopardize this process. The third part presents other sources and data related to the risky consumption of alcohol, tobacco and drugs in the Azores. Three situations are emphasized: women as victims of the consumption of others; women as victims of their own consumption and women as victimizing others due to their habits. The conclusion proposes more research on risky consumptive behavior and the implementation of a system of preventive measures.

 

1. Factors Leading to Stress in Identity Formation and Social Integration

 

The development of personal and social identity is a complex personal process, which is at times intuitive-affective, and at others verbalized, and which involves:

      personal enrichment through the development of new knowledge and values.

     affirmation of differences related to other persons and groups.

     affirmation of similarities that are favourable to one’s self-image.

     affirmation of one’s own qualities .

     exclusion of what is considered negative.

     affirmation-integration of the qualities and values of the group or groups one belongs to or wishes to belong to (See Table 1).

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Aires Gameiro, 2001.

 The attitudes, behaviour, and values of significant persons and groups, and the recognition of primary and secondary groups are basic to the development of one’s personal identity. The multiplicity of culturally different people and groups that provide elements of identification is always a decisive factor in terms of personal development.

Cultural Fragmentation, Identity and Post-modernity

Rapid socio-cultural and economic changes provide advantages but pose problems to the formation and consolidation of personal and social identity and personal balance. (See Table 2)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 Aires Gameiro, 2001.

 

1.           The multiplicity and contradiction of messages and the conflictual dynamic relationship between opinion groups, pressure groups and behavior have never had so much impact and so simultaneously. The media, television, cinema, theatre, shows, advertising, newspapers, and the Internet are seen as sources of identity in competition with the traditional sources and propose contradictory cultural fragments simultaneously. Children and young people are subject to unstable, dissonant and incoherent models.

 2.         The synchronicity and syntopy of different cultural models from different times and places characterizing this Post-modern period are another factor to consider. Layers of cultures from distant times and places compete with the cultural matrix of a people, fragment models and lead to freedom, pressure and anxiety. All who live in cities and villages are pressured by this information and by mobility to live according to culturemas1 from different periods and countries.

3.          Competition exists between the various traditional sources of personal and social identity. The family, school, religious group and acquaintances exist on a par with synchronic layers of other different cultures. These contradictory culturemas make the sedimentation of personal identity difficult. The various sources of identity referred to function without consensus and in conflict, often creating insurmountable barriers to the identity process. 

4.           More serious problems appear when peer group pressure manipulates young people in order to make them think that it is scientific and fashionable to change everything and accept the view that no foundation of permanent values exists. 

5.           In the Azores, this fragmentation and multiplicity of cultural content has been intensified with the increasing interchange between the nine islands and those from the tenth one living on the other side of the Atlantic Ocean. In addition, about 500 Azoreans with North American culture have been deported to the Azores, many of them affected by several genetic frailties and with deviational behavior.

All of these rival sources of identity affect children and young people on a daily basis. We must not forget that about 5 to 10% exhibit fragile identity due to genetic, family and environmental factors, which make them more conformist and more easily manipulated and which influence the identity formation of their partners in a negative way. We can conclude that, today, most children and young people grow up with more opportunities. At the same time, however, there has been an increase in risk factors, such as cultural conflicts, psychological insecurity, stress in decision making and problems of consumption and substance abuse. 

2. Current Cultural Opportunities and Risk Factors for Women

All of these situations are having an even greater impact on women. Being a woman was never subject to so much change. Women have never had so many different roles available to them (See Table 3).

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 Aires Gameiro, 2001.

 

The most visible effects of everything we have resumed so far are multiple:

1.   More social freedom. More options. More opportunities.

2.   More strategies for identity development and belonging within society.

3.   More pressures in more directions for a larger number of social roles.

4.   More favourable changes leading to personal and social development.

5.   More masculine developmental and occupational models available to women.

 

The other side of the coin is also unavoidable; more options bring more risks. (See Table 4) Some of these are:

 

1.   Hesitation and perplexity when facing decision making

2.   Emotional insecurity

3.   Stress and attempts at identification

4.   Instability in belonging

5.   Being more pressured and manipulated

6.   Being conditioned and in the position of a robot

7.   Evasion and risky consumption

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 Aires Gameiro, 2001.

Who am I? What am I going to do with my life? I feel insecure.

The etymology of the word stress comes from the Latin “stringere” and “strictum,” which mean to press and refer to the condition of a person being pressed. This can be defined as the bio-psycho-socio-spiritual condition of those who live under prolonged tension and conflict and can no longer return to their initial state of being. In the long term, the result is exhaustion, burn out and loss of health. Stress can result from what is unexpected or uncontrollable, or from the person’s way of being (personality). Stress starts when the person is no longer able to deal with the problem.

Emotional instability, identity conflicts, insecurity and the continuous efforts to find satisfactory personal and social identity frequently result in stress in adolescents, young adults and adults. Today, this stressful condition is aggravated by the continuous fragmentation of culture, which results in pressure to make new choices in the face of multiple, unexpected situations.  For many, returning to their initial state before stress set in becomes a problem which affects their health.

The person with an unstable identity quickly falls prey to stress and becomes burned out. When a genetic predisposition exists, as happens in 5 to 10% of persons affected by stress, the capacity to adapt satisfactorily is even more reduced or suppressed and the disturbance emerges.

Female adolescents and young adults today, maybe more than the males,2 are constantly asking themselves: who am I, what is my place in the family, in society? The struggles of feminists movements, along increasing opportunities, provoke perplexity, insecurity, difficult decision-making and problems of belonging. How should I behave? What’s the right job for me? What should I wear, when, where? How should I be a woman today? These choices can accentuate problems of identity and stress.

The wider the range of choices is, the more uncertain and insecure the person feels. A silly example would have to do with the choice between wearing a skirt or pants. When the only option for women was skirts/dresses, they felt more secure than when the choice became one skirts/dresses or pants. Today, some women have already found themselves, while others are still looking for their self-image.

Other examples would have to do with the sexual identity of women before and after the separation between the sexual and procreative dimensions, or between the alternatives to either work at home or outside the home, to pursue a college degree or not, etc. The increase in alternatives available implies opportunities and advantages, but also implies the cognitive and emotional costs of making those decisions. Do what? Be who, for what and for whom? Before, the choices, meanings and directions were fixed. Now, each one has to give meaning and direction to life.  Even if one is not aware of it, emotional stress is very strong in the process of decision making.

Emotional complexity and stress increase in relation to cultural fragmentation and the choices available. The weight of the choice falls upon the individual, except when the adolescent or young adult falls into robot-like behavior and does not take on responsibility, conforming to their partner or peer group and letting them take control.

 Conscience: A Guide or a Brake That Sometimes Doesn’t Work

            When making a choice, the female adolescent is usually alert to such questions as: Who do I follow? With whom should I conform? For how long? With what risks? She is living at the crossroads of choices involving “consumer culture,” “group consumption” and risky consumption. In such conditions, the capacity to discern critically is put to the test.

            By aligning moral conscience to cognitive and emotional capacities, most women choose that which contributes to a positive identity based on self-esteem and a valid project for development. In minor cases, these capacities are reduced and dominated by group pressure and by the attempt to avoid feeling bad or ashamed for not belonging if she doesn’t conform to the group, and this if can be truly devastating when risky behavior is involved. In this way, young girls and boys are caught between the proposals and pressures of groups when it comes to: 

1.   Cultural and developmental change, leading to positive personal identity.

2.   Stagnation and cultural rigidity that threatens positive identity development.

3.   Behavior that is evasive, deviant and risky. 

Cultural change leading to personal and social development and to the economic and political promotion of women, point to adequate choices to be made. There is, however, an overabundance of deviant behavior leading to hesitation: Work inside or outside the home? Proceed with studies or stop early? Become involved in society or remain passive? Experiment with risky behavior or not? Follow the example of my mother, my aunt, or this friend and colleague? Follow models of balanced development or those involving drugs, alcohol or tobacco?

Problems become more acute in personalities suffering from genetic, environmental, intellectual and emotional problems. One of those conditions, for example, is described by Antonio Damásio (5th ed. 1995 p. 221-230)3 as having “a myopic view of the future” in order to explain the behavior of “individuals under the influence of alcohol and other drugs.” These persons are controlled by the present and are insensitive to the future. We can say that cultural conditions lead a considerable minority of young people to function according to this weakness, and end up being led to problems of dependency on tobacco, alcohol or drugs.

 

3. Stress and Risky Consumption in Azorean Women

Let us now consider problems related to the consumption alcohol, drugs, and tobacco, with special emphasis on alcohol. In this respect, women appear as being victimized by the consumption of others and of their own consumption, and as victimizers of others due to their own consumption. It is difficult to say whether women today suffer more from their own stress and risky behavior, or if they are more in a position of being victims of the aggressive and risky behavior of others. It is more probably, as we will see, that they are more often than not the victims of the alcohol and drugs abuse of others, and more victims of their own smoking habits and of aggressive behavior toward their children. There is, nonetheless, an overabundance of situations in which their abuse of alcohol hurts their children, especially during periods of pregnancy and breastfeeding.

Traditionally, however, men have been more prone to aggressive behavior, possibly due to genetic weaknesses and to the macho tendencies of a patriarchal society than to defending female victims. Almost everything seems to impede these victims from defending themselves and finding alternatives leading to liberation and self-fulfillment.

There are increasing signs that some changes are occurring, at times amidst stress, personal identity dilemmas, pressure groups and risky choices, and sometimes with no return possible. While adult women tend to take refuge in the past and stay in situations where they are victimized and under stress, young women, along with being victims, tend to react by evading and selling-out their future through risky behavior and consumption.

Recent Data About Risky Consumption on a National and Azorean Level    

            We are only beginning to do research in terms of the effects of alcohol on third parties, especially women and children. The data is still scarce and dispersed. The effects of smoking on non-smokers is the area that has been most studied, while studies on alcohol involve more and more research projects. Drug abuse has been the most visible area and the one attracting the most funding. Not being able to review all of the material, I will present some data pertaining to the Azores in relation to alcohol, tobacco and drug abuse.

 ALCOHOL

1.   Alcoholics Anonymous Questionnaire. 25 to 30% of AA declare that they jeopardize themselves and jeopardize others.

 A recent poll conducted by Alcoholics Anonymous (1999) included 413 members from 70 groups in all of Portugal, including the Azores and Madeira Islands,4 presents some pertinent data (See Table 5). Of the 413 interviewed, 94 were women (23%) and 314 (77%) men, which gives us a ration of 3 to 1. Boys began to consume alcohol at an earlier age, that is 55% before the age of 17, while 23% of the girls also started before 17 and 58.6% after 20. Of the women, 25.5% and 34.8% of the men indicated that their reason for starting to participate in AA meetings had to do with family presure, indicating that they were already jeapordizing the family. On the other hand, 31.9% of the women and 19.7% of the men indicate emotional problems, while 8.5% of the women and 9.1% of the men point to physical deterioration.

 

Table 5

AA Study1999

                  N=413                     M=314                      F=94

                                                    77%                         23%

                                                              M %           Age            F %

Introduction to alcohol                           55        Before 17         23

Problems                                                 15        Before 20           8  

Reasons for going to AA:

- Family pressures                                 34.8                             25.5

- Emotional degredation                        19.7                             31.9

- Physical detereoration                          9.1                               8.5

Source: E. Serviços Gerais de AA.

         2.   Alcoholics under treatement. From a small sample of 100 alcoholics undergoing treatment in the center where I worked until 1998, the majority recognized alcohol as a co-factor in their family’s problems. (See Table 6).     

  

Table 6

Awareness of 100 alcoholics under treatment having the notion that  they provoked problems to their

families due to their dependency5 in the 80’s

      Status                                    Single                                     22%

                                                    Married                                 62   

                                                    Divorced                                  9   

                                                    With children                         66   

      Problems                               Family problems                     94   

          and                                    Jealousy in terms of wife        29   

     Prejudices                              Forgets the family                  54   

                                                    Makes the family unhappy     92   

                                                    Separation due to drinking    33   

Note: The % are equal to absolute values.                        

Source: Aires Gameiro, 1994.

 3.   About 5.0% of male alcoholics in the Azores jeopardize their wives and children.

 In the study we conducted in the Azores in 1999,6 only 5.0% of alcoholic men declared that their drinking affected others. Of these, 70% indicated their wives and 20% indicated their children as being affected. On the other hand, only 1.8% of women alcoholics admitted that they affected their husband and children, their parents and siblings. In both cases, it is probable that these numbers are underestimated for reasons of self-defense and negation of the problems, both very common in problems of dependency.

The Alcohol of the “Aggressors” as Seen by Victimized Wome

            1.   About 6.72% of women in national study were victimized due to the alcohol abuse of the aggressors.

 In the Study Alcohol and the Family (EUROCARE-SAAP/COFACE-CNAF 1997), there is a study (Violence Against Women 1997 p.87-89) with samples representing 1,000 women above the age of 18 in which the victims declared that 16% of their aggressors consumed alcohol and 84% did not consume. When asked if there was a relationship between alcohol or drug abuse and the violence they had suffer, 42% responded affirmatively and 10% said they didn’t know, which results in 6.72% of those victims having perceived the relationship.

 2.   About 50% of the SOS victims were the result of alcohol abuse.

 In terms of 80 women assisted by SOS Vitima (Angra 2001), the aggressor is a male alcoholic in 50% of the cases, and dependent in 9% of the cases, with no indications as to whether the victims perceived the relationship to alcohol and drugs (See Table 7).

 

Table 7

Alcoholic Agressors in a Group of 80 Cases

S.O.S. Vitima (Angra, March 2001)7

           Characteristics of the Aggressor          N                   %         

           Alcoholic                                             40                  50        

           Behavioral Problems                           25                  31        

           Drug Dependency                               7                    9          

           Adultery                                               6                    8          

           Handicapped                                       2                    9          

           TOTAL                                                80                  

 3.   About 6.5% of Azorean women are victims of alcoholic aggressors.

 In the book The Situation of Women in the Azores (1999), 6.5% of the 2000 women recognized some relationship between the violence they suffered and the alcohol problems of their aggressors. This percentage is near the 6.72 referred above. From this study, we include Table 8 (p.185).

 

Table 8

Relationship Between Violence Suffered and Alcohol and Drug Abuse8

                    Itens                                           %        

              Often                                               1.6       

              Sometimes                                       2.9       

              Seldom                                            2.0       

              Never                                             21.3      

              Don’t Know/No Answer                 72.2      

              TOTAL                                         100.0     

Source: Situation of Women in the Azores, 1999.

As the authors state, the high percentage of 72.1%  of the women who do not know or do not respond, pointing to a “reserved attitude,” means that this can not be understood as lack of knowledge or perception. In our estimation, these point to the tendency to negate, hide and feel ashamed of the situations in which they find themselves due to affective ties or to their own substance abuse. When the questions pertain to less affective issues, the percentages pertaining to these same women are much higher, 62.9% totally disagree with alcohol and 27.7% simply disagree, a total percentage of 90.6% (p.69 and 70). The authors point out that “Alcoholism is more prejudicial, perhaps it has been more a part of the daily life of many women because of their husbands, fathers, brothers or other close acquaintance.” (p.69-70) and that “We know how alcoholism in women of all ages, including adolescents and children, has increased in the last few years.” (p.70) Based on the last three sources, we can conclude that about 5-7% of women are beaten by their husbands because of alcohol.  

4.   10% of aggressions against women are due to alcohol

 In a telephone interview, 200 women from São Miguel Island (See Table 9 for technical information) were asked about their own habits in terms of alcohol consumption and the consequences, and were also questioned about the habits of their male partners and the results of this behavior.

 

Table 9

Drinking Habits of Women Who Consume Alcohol

in São Miguel (2001)

Technical Information

Author: Aires Gameiro

N=200 women living 15 or more years in the Island of  São Miguel      

Date: May 19 and 20, 2001

Method: Telephone interview (73.1%) (27% of the homes were excluded because they had no telephone)

Margin for Error: +- 6.9

Interviews and Calculations: Norma-Açores

Sponsorship: Instituto S. João de Deus

 Of the 200 women, 43.5% admitted to consuming alcoholic beverages and 73.5% to having a husband, companion or boyfriend who consumes; 54% of these last women also drink. (See Table 10). The level of consciousness women have of the damage brought about by their own consumption and by that of their husbands is indicated in Table 11. In all, 19.6% of the consumers feel that alcohol is prejudicial to their health, (17.2%) to their lives, and (5.7%) to the lives of their family members and others (1 to 3.5%).

 

Table 10

Women and Alcohol in São Miguel Island

N=200 Aires Gameiro, Jun-01

   Women                        %                 Husbands                             %

   Consume                   43.5               Have a husband                73.5         

   Do not consume        56.5               Do not                               26.5         

                                                          Husbands consume            40.0         

                                                          Do not consume                 33.5         

Total                           100.0                                                       100.0        

Of the 73.5% who have husband      

Consume                                                                                      54.0         

Do not consume                                                                           46.0         

                                                                                                   100.0        

 Of the husbands who drink (54%), 26.2% are perceived by the women to be prejudicial to: his health (25%), to her health (10%), 7.5% to the children’s health and 3.8% to the life of others. The conclusion was that 10% of the alcoholic aggressors cause some kind of damage to women due to alcohol.

 Other Results of this Study

 In the area of Ribeira Grande, 45% drink and 33.4% of the women state that this is jeopardizing their health and 14.3% the life of others, while in the Lagoa area 41.2% drink and 14.3% declare this to be prejudicial to their lives. The husbands who drink in the City of Ribeira Grande (42.5%) are the ones who are seen as jeopardizing their health most, 23.5 as jeopardizing the woman’s life and the family. The highest percentage seen as not jeopardizing (47.1%) also occurs in Ribeira Grande.

In terms of schooling, women with Higher Education are those who consume alcohol most, at 80% and 53.8% for those who have attended junior high school. In accord with this, 50.0% of their husbands with similar educational levels also drink

 

Table 11

% of Women, Husbands and Alcohol in São Miguel

(Awareness of the Consequences)

 

                       N=200                                        Aires Gameiro, Jun-01

            The 43.5% of Female                    The 54% of Drinking

                    Consumers                                     Husbands

                Who Jeopardize                             Who Jeopardize

                                                       %                                            %

Her health                       17.2 (1)   His health                           25 (1)   

Her life                                 5.7     His life                                  10      

The husband’s life                1.1      His life                                  10      

Other family member            3.4      The childrens’ life                  7.5    

Other persons                       2.3      The life of other persons        3.8

Do not jeopardize              78.2      Do not jeopardize                72.5

Don’t know/ Don’t answer   2.2      Don’t know/ Don’t answer    1.3

Total: No answers              80.4      Total: No answers                73.8     Total yes answers  19.6     Total yes answers                                           26.2

(1) Multiple Answers.                     

Source: Aires Gameiro, 2001.

                      Urban areas (Ponta Delgada and Ribeira Grande) present the highest percentages of female consumption of alcohol, at 52.6%, compared to 39.9% in rural areas. However, when it comes to the smaller villages, women drink even more (62.5%) with an average of 43.5%.

 
Note: All of this data may be below real levels since 27% of the homes were not included because they did not have telephone service.

 

Table 12

Summary

                                                                                                                                        

1.           From the total number, 43.5% of the women, and 54% of the husbands drink. 19.6% of the women who drink put themselves or their families in jeopardy, while the percentage for men is 26.2%, with 10% jeopardizing their own lives.

2.           While of the women who drink, only 1.1% admit to jeopardizing their husbands, 10% recognize that their husband’s drinking jeopardizes them. We have here an assymetrical ratio of 1 to 10.           

3.           The city of Ribeira Grande, followed by Lagoa, present the highest percentages of those who jeopardize themselves and others. The highest percentage of husbands who jeopardize their wives, children and other family members occurs in the city of Ribeira Grande.

4.           On the other hand, it is the women and husbands with a university level of education, followed by the junior high level, who drink more and jeopardize their own health the most.          

5.           And, finally, it is in the urban areas of Ponta Delgada and Ribeira Grande where women consume the most alcohol, but it is in villages with less than 1,000 inhabitants that the highest percentage of women who drink alcohol is registered.        

 

24.5% of the men and 28.8% of the women in the Azores drink too much.

 In a study from 1999 representing 550 participants who were 15 years old or older, we came up with the following results:

 1.       If we consider the habit of consuming 6 to 9 alcoholic drinks per week, we come up with Table 13.

 

 Table 13

Azores – Alcoholic Consumption

         Consumes               Drinks         M           F                 Ratio M/F

                                       Per Day        %           %                        

2 to 3 times week(1)             1           23.4        7.7                    3.0/1

1 per day                             3           16.2        2.8                    5.7/1

3 to 5 times a day            3 to 15        8.3          0                     8.3/1

Total                                                  47.9       10.5                   5.0/1

(1) Average of 3 drinks each time.                                                                         

Source: Aires Gameiro, 2000.

                                Even if we consider that women become intoxicated with about half the consumption of men, and that three drinks per day is already excessive drinking for women and for many men, only 2.8% of Azorean women abuse alcohol, compared to 24.5% of men, that is, about 1women to 8 men.

 2.       The same study indicates the numbers of those who have never consumed alcohol or quit and the reasons. (p. 44 and 64). (See Table 14).

 

Table 14

Azores – Have Never Drunk or Quit

                                                                   M        F              Ratio

                                                                   %        %        M/F or F/M         

Never                                                         9.8     30.5                  3.1/1        

For health reasons                                   23.1    50.6                  2.1/1        

Quit more than 10 years ago                    14.4    10.2      1.4/1        

Do not like                                                10.5    24.1                     

For health reasons                                   84.2    75.9      1.1/1        

Source: Aires Gameiro, 2000.

 

For every male, 3 women totally abstain from drinking alcohol due to health reasons and recognizing that they are more sensitive to the damages of alcohol. The reasons for The reasons for quitting have to do with health and with not liking drinking. Women are most sensitive to health reasons, indicating that they may have quit because their health was already affected.

 

3. There is a great disparity between the opinions of men and women with respect to the number of cups/day that do not have negative effects, as seen in Table 15.

  

Table 15

Azores – How many cups/day do not have negative effects?              Cups/Day9

                                                           M      F                           M      F

                                                           %      %                           %      %

1 cup/day                                         30.9  40.7              1       23.4   7.7       

3 cups/day                                        14.0   6.0               3       16.4   2.8       

4 and 5 cups/day                               6.8    1.4          4 to 15   8.3      0

It’s impolite to refuse alcoholic drinks?    13.6            6.7                                      

Last drink: today                              29.1   4.5            Total    47.9  10.5

Source: Aires Gameiro, 2000.

                                      This difference between men and women is also apparent in the answers about whether refusing alcoholic drinks is impolite and about the last drink consumed that day.

 TOBACCO

 28.6% of men and 26.6% of women smoke.

According to the same study (Aires Gameiro 2000), there is a difference between alcohol consumption and the use of tobacco by women, as can be seen in Table 16. 

 

Table 16

Azores – Use of Tobacco

                                                   T       M      F       Ratio  Young People

                                                   %       %      %        M/F    15-17  18-24

Have smoked                           42.2   63.4  22.5     2.8/1    22.7    50.6        

Continue to smoke                   28.0   28.6  26.6     1.1/1    20.0    29.5

Source: Aires Gameiro 2000.

 According to this table, we can see that 2/3 of males and 1/4 of females 15 and over who have alredy smoked, about 3 men to 1 woman. Of these, about one quarter continue to smoke. This seems to indicate that smoking is more accepted by women and that it has become fashionable among young women as a way of self-affirmation.

These numbers are different from the 15% of women in a 1990-1992 study conducted in Portugal by OMS-Europa10 which also registered a tendency for the use of tobacco to decrease among men and to increase among women (p.11). At the same time, this study presents similar findings for 12-18 year olds, with equal rates for boys and girls until the age of 16 (p.13), that is, 8.2%  for 12-14, and 22.7%  for 15-16,

A national study11 from 1997 indicates that in Portugal 38% of men and 9.0% of women had smoked during the last month, with a percentage of 24.2% of young people of both sexes between 15-24. These are finding which show that the 1999 findings for women in the Azores are significantly above, while the findings for men are below the national average. The 15-17 year olds and the 18-24 year olds continue to demonstrate smoking levels near the national average.

DRUGS

 

1.15% of Azoreans Consume Drugs.

 

Obtaining reliable data about drug abuse continues to be difficult. We have tried to organize the data that follows.

 

1.      In the study already referred to (Aires Gameiro 2000), data was collected without separating men and women, as seen in Table 17, which indicates consumption of any kind of drug. If we consider those over 15 years of age, we have 13,400 who have already consumed and 2,170 for those who declare that they still consume some kind of drugs, except alcohol or tobaco.

  

Table 17

Azores (1999)

Consumption of Any Type of Drug

                                                      %                      Population          

Have consumed                            6.7                       13.400 

Still consume                                1.15                      2.170  

Source: Aires Gameiro.

 2.       Considering first-time hospitalization of men and women, who are drug addicts, we find that in 1998, 1999 and 2000, 248 men and 33 women came to Clínica S. João de Deus to be treated, which results in 7.5 men for every woman. Heroin users look for treatment most often. We are not including those treated in out-patient care. (See Table 18).

  

Table 18

Clínica S. J. Deus/Casa de Saúde S. Miguel

HOSPITALIZATION DUE TO DRUG ABUSE

PERIOD: 1991-2000

               MASCULINE                      FEMININE                              TOTAL      

                1 time   2 t.    Total           1 time    2 t.    Total           1 time    2 t.    TOTAL

1991           5         1          6                   0          0          0                    5          1           6               

1992           1         0          1                   0          0          0                    1          0           1               

1993           7         0          7                   0          0          0                    7          0           7               

1994          14        0        14                  0          0          0                  14         0          14              

1995           8         1          9                   0          0          0                    8          1           9               

1996           6         4        10                  0          0          0                    6          4          10              

1997          23        4        27                  0          0          0                  23         4          27              

1998          62        7        69                 11         3         14                 73        10         83              

1999          88       30      118                13         8         21                101      38        139            

2000          98       67      165                 9         21        30                107      88        195            

TOTAL    312     114     426                33        32        65                345     146       491         

                                        

  We began a Methadone treatment in January of 2000 for 131 men and 17 women. Of those who started then, 84 men and 7 women remain, while 57 men and 10 women dropped out. In terms of deportees, 51 men and 11 women, a total of 62, were hospitalised at the Clínica S. João de Deus. This number represents about 1/6 of the total of deportees now in the Azores.

 3.       We will now summarize the data collected by the Special Committee of the Regional Legislative Assemby, May 2000, and compare these findings with our study. (Please see summary Table 19 by institution, and Table 20 by island).

 

Table 19

Numbers Referring to Drug Consumption from the Report

May of 2000 -  the Regional Legislative Assembly12

    Entities and                                   Average                    Average                        Type of

    Institutions                        M            Age            F            Age            T              Drug 

Schools

Parent Associations               12          15-20           9           14-16          21            hax/alc               

Private Institution for              4              60              9             70            13      alc dep/her/coc         

Social Solidarity (IPSS)    40 (18)(1)      30              8             29            48

Health Centers                      230         20-25          71            22           301     her/coc/hax/alc

Psychiatric Hospitals /

Health Centers                      272         25-30          57          20-30         329        her/coc/hax

                                            -17(2)           

Police Stations / Prisons       166

Social Institutions                -45(3)       25-30          10          20-30         176        her/hax/coc

Total de M + F less

those repeated                       644                           156                           880                

(1) 18 sent to Clínica S. João de Deus.                                                                                                                        

(2) 17 seen by other doctors or sent to Clínica SJD/Casa de Saúde S. Miguel.

(3) 45 sent to C.S.J.D./Alternativa/C. Saúde da Horta.

 
Comparing Estimates

 Table 21 compares the estimates from our October 1999 study with the data obtained by the Special Commission in May of 2000.

  

Table 20

Distribution of Drug Users According to Islands

                                   M               F              T             Type of Drug

S. Miguel                            331                  52                383               hax/alc/coc/her

Terceira                              357                  98                455                       hax/her

Faial                                    21                     4                  25                        hax/her

                                                                                        +20(1)                          

Pico                                       2                      1                    3                         hax/coc

Flores                                    3                      -                    3                               -

Total                                    714                 155            869(2)

                                                                                           +20                     

(1) 20 not specified as M and F.                                                                                                                                    

(2) We were unable to adjust this figure with that of the previous Table.

 

Table 21

Comparison of the Data from the 1999 Study

With those of the Special Committee in 2000

                                                                       M          F            T           Pop.

                                                                                                                          %

October 1999 Study           Consume                                     -            -           6.7        12.750

Aires Gameiro                   Still consume                                                        1.15        2.170

Report of Special Commssion,                                             644        156        800          800

May 2000                                                                           0.34%   0.08%   0.42%          

 

From these results, we can safely conclude that:

     1.           The “generic” drug abusers (present poli-consumers) in the Region between from 1999 to 2000 numbered about  2,200.

     2.      The Report of the Special Commission detected less than 50% because these were the ones who sought help.

     3.      We can then estimate that at least 1.15% of the population of persons 15 or older consumed in 2000 and about 6.7% had experimented.

     4.      For each female consumer, we estimate four males.

These figures are probably below the real figures.

 More Research Is Needed

 It is necessary that more research be conducted in order to reach a more objective analysis of the relationship between the victimizer who consumes alcohol and violence against women, so that we can discriminate between the various factors involved. More research should be done in the following areas:

 1.   presence of alcohol.

2.   quantity consumed and effects.

3.   relationship to the co-factor of aggression and violence.

4.   type of aggression and abuse.

5.   awareness of the relationship between drinking and its consequences.

6.   awareness of the relationship between the aggressor’s drinking and the violence suffered.

 

Final Considerations

 

1.           To the common “lack of perception and tendency to hide the violence,”13 we would add the sense of shame and taboo associated with having a problem of alcohol affecting the family, the husband or the father. 

2.           The representations of women vary according to the consumption of alcohol and the alcoholism of the man, depending on whether the woman feels that she cannot live without the man or that she can no longer put up with him. 

3.           An important factor has to do with women themselves consuming excessive alcohol and living with this problem. The tendency to deny also alters their perception. The emancipation and economic independence of women is increasing the number of women drinkers, making them more tolerant of aggression resulting from alcohol. 

4.           There remains a need to clarify what levels of alcohol consumption are prone to cause problems in terms of the family and women, as well as what the levels of tolerance are, what the expected effects of alcohol are, and what is seen as acceptable/not acceptable in terms of drinking by men. The relationship between violence and alcohol can lead one to think of excessive consumption and drunkenness, or of light / Social drinking which alters moods and reactions. The drinker with epileptic tendencies or with psychic disturbances can become drunk or affected when medication is stopped or mixed with alcohol, even in small quantities.

5.           Ideas about alcohol must also be considered in terms of those who drink in excess or in a dependent way, even when their behavior is altered, for neither they nor those around them discern any problem unless they become completely drunk. Women also deny their husband’s drinking problem until the family’s money disappears, changes in personality become repeated and threats and abuse increase. Even then, many women will continue to deny their spouse’s problem because of shame.

6.           The perception of being a victim or not varies according to the concept a culture has of violence and to levels of tolerance. Does it include physical abuse, abusive language, or only physical aggression that leaves marks on the body? It can even be interpreted as not being violent by the woman who says, “My husband doesn’t beat me, and if he ever does, it’s because I deserve it.”

  While it is true that alcohol can be used as an alibi for men and women to excuse their inadequacies and to relieve tension, we must not forget that many of the small-big problems with alcohol start precisely when drinking relieves tension and awakens emotions. We may conclude by saying that more research is necessary so that we can have a better idea about the dimensions of the damages caused by smoking, drinking and drug use to those who do not partake of these intoxicating substances, but are exposed to these types of behavior.

  Bibliography

 A.A.  Sondagem aos Membros de Alcoólicos Anónimos, Outubro de 1999. Lisboa: Escritório de Serviços Gerais,1999.

CANÇO, Dina and CASTRO, Isabel. (2000). Portugal: Situação das Mulheres 1999, 15ª edição CIDM.

CANHA, Jeni. (2000). Criança maltratada. Papel de uma pessoa de referência na sua recuperação. Coimbra.

COMISSÃO Nacional da Pastoral da Saúde. Mulher Informada. Maternidade Saudável – Desafios e Propostas, Lisboa.

DAMÁSIO, António (1995). O erro de Descartes. Emoção, Razão e Cérebro Humano, 5ª edição. Lisboa.

EDWARDS, Griffith, ANDERSON Peter et al. (1997).  A Política do Álcool e o Bem Comum. Lisboa.

GAMEIRO Aires et al. (1988). Pessoas Dependentes (Drogas, Álcool...). Ed. Hospitalidade and Cáritas. 

GAMEIRO, Aires, MOREIRA, Mª João, CARVALHO, Gualter de, and RUIVO, Mª José. (1998).  Alcohol Problems and the Family Report, SAAP.

GAMEIRO, Aires. (1983). Álcool, Alcoolismo e Drogodependência – Recuperação através da reestruturação inter-relacional e sistémica. Lisboa: Ed. Hospitalidade.

______Alcoolismo na Interacção Sistémica - Aspectos psicossociais da Alcooldependência – Editorial Hospitalidade, 1981.

______Alcoolismo nos Açores e Madeira. Padrões de consumo em 1999 e 2000. Linhas de Prevenção. Lisboa: Ed. Hospitalidade, 2000.

______Emigrantes. Psicologia Social, Conflitos e Desafios Culturais. Lisboa: Centro do Livro Brasileiro, 1984.

______Hábitos de consumo de bebidas alcoólicas 1995, 1991, 1997, Lisboa: Ed. Hospitalidade, 1998.

______Liberdade de beber e de não beber. Saúde e pressões relativas ao consumo de destiliados, cerveja e vinho. De colaboração com o Dr. Saturnino e outros. Lisboa, Ed. Hospitalidade, 1987.

______Lusofonia e Identidade na Diáspora. Análises psicossociais. Lisboa: Ed. Paulinas, 2000.

______Manual de Saúde Mental e Psicopatologia. Guia Prático de acompanhamento na Saúde Mental e na Doença Nervosa. 4ª Ed. de “Psicopatologia e Saúde Mental”, with five chapters on Social and Community Psychatry. Porto: Ed. Salesianas. 1989.

______Novos Horizontes da Viuvez. Crise, Acompanhamento, Psicologia, Novo Projecto e Pastoral. Lisboa: Ed. Paulistas,1988.

HARKIN, Anna May, ANDERSON, Peter and GOOS, Cees. (1997).  Smoking, drinking and drug taking in the European Region. Copenhagen: WHO Europe.

JUNAAB. (1997). AA Para a mulher, 7ª ed. Portugal.

LAY, William & RUTHERFORD, Derek. (1998). Alcohol problems in the family. A report in the family. England.

LOURENÇO, Nelson, LISBOA, Manuel & PAIS, Elza. (1997). Violência contra as mulheres na família – caracterização das representações sociais e práticas de violência em relação à mulher. Lisboa: CIDM.

MCNEILL, Andrew. (1999). Medical Education in Alcohol and Alcohol Problems, EUROCARE: England.

MENDES, Maria Fernanda. (2000). Relatório sobre a problemática da droga na Região Autónoma dos Açores. Ponta Delgada.

PLATON, Alex. European Alcohol Action Plan, WHO Copenhagen 1993.

ROCHA, Gilberta, MEDEIROS, Octávio, TOMÁS, Licínio, MADEIRA, Artur and BORRALHO, Álvaro. (1999). A Situação das mulheres nos Açores. Ponta Delgada.

RODRIGUES, Luísa, MENDES, Zilda and ANTUNES, Carla. (1997). (ESPAD) Inquérito a Alunos do Ensino Secundário: Portugal 1995. Lisboa.

STEELE, C.M and R.A. Joseph (1990). “Alcohol myopia” in American Psychologist 45: 921-33. Cited by António Damásio (1995).

 ____________________

*    Participated in the Conference A Mulher nos Açores e nas Comunidades, July 16-18, 2001, University of the Azores.

 

   Homepage       Forschung-Übersicht        Seite oben            English texts

 

 

Inhaltsverzeichnis 

Entwicklungen der schweizerischen Alkoholpolitik der letzten Jahre anhand von Leserbriefen

Aktuell

Hinweise für Unterrichtende

Ihre Meinung interressiert uns

Links zu Fachleuten und Institutionen

Internationales

Briefe an ....

Die Lobby-Arbeit der globalen Alkoholindustrie

Veranstaltungen

Parlamentsdebatten

Zitatensammlung

Newsletter

Forschungsergebnisse

Archiv

English Texts      

Dossiers: Suchtmittelwerbung; Alcopops; Absinth; WTO - GATS; Alkoholkonsum Jugendlicher; Alkohol und Verkehr /  Drink Driving; Wein (Alkohol) sei (mässig genossen) gesund; Sport und Alkohol; Strukturelle Prävention; NPA (Nationales Programm Alkohol); botellón

Geschichten

Interventionen

Wir über uns

Projekt-Idee     Project in English


Herausgeber/Editor:

Hermann T. Meyer, Projekte und Dienstleistungen, Lindenstr. 32, CH-8307 Effretikon, Switzerland, 
Tel. +41 (0)52 343 58 75, Fax: +41 (0)52 343 59 29    e-mail

Copyright © 2001-2008: Hermann T. Meyer. Alle Rechte vorbehalten. Unsere eigenen Texte dürfen gerne unter Quellenangabe übernommen und weiterverbreitet werden. Fremde Texte entsprechen nicht unbedingt unserer eigenen Auffassung.

All rights reserved. Our own texts may be copied and distributed with stating the source. Texts from other sources do not necessarily represent our views.

Stand: 23.12.2008